Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Little Fish menu

13 dishes across 5 sections $50 to $100 Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Little Fish photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Little Fish photo menu 1 Little Fish photo menu 2 Little Fish photo menu 3 Little Fish photo menu 4 Little Fish photo menu 5 Little Fish photo menu 6

White Wine 11 dishes

  • Borghese Sauv Blanc '21 Cutchogue, LI $60.00

  • Doranda Coste Della Sesia Bianco '20 Lessona, IT $65.00

  • Paumanok Chenin Blanc '23 Aquebogue, NY $64.00

  • Perlinas Albarino, Rias Baixas, Spain $62.00

  • RGNY Viognier '21 Riverhead. LI $70.00

  • Limizzani Vermentino '22 Sardina, IT $56.00

  • Cakebread Chardonnay '22 Napa Valley, CA $90.00

  • Influence Reisling '21 Finger Lakes, NY $50.00

  • Clos Margot Chorey Les Beaune '20 Bourgogne, FR $102.00

  • Corey Creek Coquillage Chardonnay '19 Southold, LI $64.00

  • Bastion Picp Oul De Pinet '23 Languedoc, FR $52.00

Raw Bites 3 dishes

  • Beach Day Ceviche* $23.00

    Local Catch, Fresh Lime Juice, Red Onion, Sumac, EVOO, Homemade Tortilla Chips. GLUTEN + DAIRY FREE

  • Spicy Tuna Tartare Taquitos* $18.00

    Avocado, local micro greens, sriracha, and toasted sesame seeds. DAIRY FREE

  • Mermaid Makeout Oysters* $12.00

    Herb oil, charred pineapple relish, cracked pink peppercorn, and classic mignonette. GLUTEN + DAIRY FREE

Sparkling & Champagne 4 dishes

  • Fiol Prosecco NV Treviso, Italy $56.00

  • Pol Roger Champagne NV Epernay, FR 756 $92.00

  • Charles Heidsieck Champagne Rose NV Reims, FR $120.00

  • Sparkling Pointe TOPAZ Rosé, Southold NY $75.00

Signature Snacks 3 dishes

  • Korean BBQ Duck Wings $18.00

    Homemade Korean BBQ sauce, chives, and toasted sesame seeds. GLUTEN + DAIRY FREE

  • Smokey The Eggplant $19.00

    Roasted, Mediterranean Seasoned, Smoked Paprika & Garlic Oil, Popped Sorghum. GLUTEN FREE + VEGAN

  • Little Fish Cornbread $15.00

    Our signature little fish shaped cornbread, baked to order. Served with Honey Butter

Lunch Menu 14 dishes

  • Beach Day Ceviche* $23.00

    Local Catch, Fresh Lime Juice, Red Onion, Sumac, EVOO, Homemade Tortilla Chips

  • Grilled 8oz 'Pat LaFrieda' Burger* $29.00

    Aged Cheddar, tomato jam, pickled onions, Calabrian chili aioli, and French fries.

  • Mermaid Makeout Oysters* $12.00

    Dairy free, gluten free. Herb oil, charred pineapple relish, cracked pink peppercorn, and classic mignonette.

  • 'The Shack' Lobster Roll $44.00

    Served on a fresh baked croissant coleslaw and old bay potato chips.

  • 'Not Your Mamas' Mezze $23.00

    Local beet hummus mint raita, ezme, grilled olives, and marinated feta cheese.

  • Charred Lemon Caesar Salad* $20.00

    House-made dressing, prima Donna cheese, fresh dill, and crispy croissant croutons.

  • Grilled Shishito Peppers $15.00

    Gluten free, vegan. Furikake seasoning, imported olive oil, Malden salt, and charred lemon.

  • Spicy Tuna Tartare Taquitos* $18.00

    Dairy free, spicy. Avocado, local micro greens sriracha, and toasted sesame seeds.

  • Korean BBQ Duck Wings $18.00

    Dairy free, gluten free. Homemade Korean BBQ sauce, chives, and toasted sesame seeds.

  • Avocado Toast Grand Bazaar $23.00

    Vegan. Local 1610 Sourdough Bread, Smashed Avocado, Za’atar, Sumac, EVOO, Arugula

  • Blackened Fish Mon Tacos $26.00

    Gluten free. Creamy coleslaw, mango salsa, and homemade crunchy corn tortillas.

  • Green Goddess Crab $26.00

    Local Lettuce, Avocado, Heart of Palm, Green Goddess Dressing

  • Grilled Chicken Croissantwich $25.00

    Organic Chicken, Chipotle Mayo, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, French Fries

  • Wild Fennel Mussels $20.00

    Local wild fennel shallots, herb butter, white wine, Pernod, and grilled sourdough.

Signature Cocktails 7 dishes

  • Halekulani $17.00

    Montauk Peach Whiskey, Pineapple Juice, Brown Sugar Syrup, Fresh Lemon Juice

  • Chinosa $15.00

    Prosecco passion fruit liquor.

  • Big Fish Punch $18.00

    White & Spiced Rum, Fresh Fruit Juices, Goslings Floater.

  • The Shack Signature Margarita's $17.00

    Maestro Dobel Cristalino Reposado, Cointreau Orange Liquor, Fresh Lime Juice. Choice of Classic, Spicy, Tamarind, or Passion fruit.

  • The Oxacan Dove $17.00

    Mezcalum Artisnal Mezcal, Fresh Grapefruit Juice, Cointreau, Lime.

  • The Classic Dark N' Stormy $17.00

    Goslings Rum, Fresh Lime Juice, Regatta Ginger Beer.

  • The Barbary Pirate $17.00

    Gray whale gin, Turkish sumac syrup. Fresh lime ginger Thai basil.

Rose 4 dishes

  • Bedell Rosé '23 Cutchogue, NY $52.00

  • Sainte Marguerite Symphonie '23 Provence, FR $64.00

  • Chateau Minuty M Rose '23 Provence, FR $70.00

  • Maison Mirabeau "PURE" Rosé '23 $75.00

BEER 8 dishes

  • Corona Lt $7.00

  • Budweiser $7.00

  • Miller Lt. $7.00

  • Pacifico (Draft) $8.00

  • Budweiser Lt. $7.00

  • Guiness Draught Can $8.00

  • Peroni $7.00

  • Guinness Draught Can $8.00

Kids Food 5 dishes

  • Kids Noodles $14.00

    Butter Soba Noodles.

  • Grilled Cheese $14.00

    Comes with French fries & ketchup.

  • Grilled Fish $15.00

    Served with French Fries

  • Chicken Fingers $14.00

    Comes with French Fries and ketchup.

  • Kids Pizza & Fries $16.00

    Locally sourced from Terry's Pizza's in Mattituck. 1/2 of delicious thin crust margarita pizza and side of crispy fries.

House Specialties 10 dishes

  • Grilled Local Catch 2 LB $70.00

    Butterflied, head on, mostly deboned. Chimichurri, Grilled Lemon. GLUTEN + DAIRY FREE

  • Red Dragon Noodles $24.00

    Dairy free. Local clams, soba noodles, Calabrian chili, coconut broth, cilantro, and sesame. DAIRY FREE

  • Hot Honey Jerk Ribs $32.00

    Slow Cooked Baby Back Ribs, Creamy Cilantro Slaw,, House-made Glaze. GLUTEN FREE

  • 1 LB Prime Dry Aged Ribeye $75.00

    Bone-in 16oz PRIME cut from Pat La Frieda NYC Butchers: Ancho-Coffee Dry Rubbed, Mezcal Peppercorn Demi Glace. Served with side of seasonal vegetable. GLUTEN FREE

  • Grilled Local Catch 1LB $38.00

    Butterflied, head on, mostly deboned. Chimichurri, Grilled Lemon. GLUTEN + DAIRY FREE

  • Swordfish Milanese $37.00

    Roasted seaweed butter, local greens pickled onions, feta, and grilled lemon.

  • Mushroom Fried Rice $28.00

    Gluten free, vegan. Mattituck Mushrooms, Vegan Kimchi, Hijiki, Pickled Onion, Scallion, GLUTEN FREE + VEGAN

  • Piri Piri Half Chicken $36.00

    Local organic chicken, aji amarillo, and salsa Verde. Served with seasonal local vegetable side. GLUTEN FREE

  • Monk Fish Tikka Masala $42.00

    Tender local monk fish, mint raita, homemade tikka sauce, and wild rice. GLUTEN FREE

  • Grilled Local Catch 1.5 LB $45.00

    Butterflied, head on, mostly deboned. Chimichurri, Grilled Lemon. GLUTEN + DAIRY FREE

Classics 3 dishes

  • Grilled 'Pat LaFrieda' Burger* $29.00

    Aged Cheddar, tomato jam, pickled onions, Calabrian chili aioli, and French fries.

  • Blackened Fish Mon Tacos $26.00

    Creamy coleslaw, mango salsa, and homemade crunchy corn tortillas. This item is shipped unassembled to preserve quality!!! GLUTEN FREE

  • 'The Shack' Lobster Roll $44.00

    Served on a fresh baked croissant coleslaw and old bay potato chips.

Red Wine 10 dishes

  • Chateaux D'Arsac Margaux '19 Bordeaux, FR $86.00

  • McCall 'Reserve' Merlot '14 Cutchogue, LI $65.00

  • M. Chapoutier Belleruche '22 Côtes-Du-Rhone, FR $52.00

  • Benton - Lane Pinot Noir '22 Willamette, OR $60.00

  • McCall 'Reserve' Pinot Noir '14 Cutchogue, LI $108.00

  • Rainoldi Nebbiolo '20 Chiuro, IT $75.00

  • Oberon Cabernet Sauvignon '21 Napa County, CA $70.00

  • Macari Bergen Road '20 Aquebogue, NY $96.00

  • Orin Swift Machete '20 St Helena, CA $120.00

  • La Macinaia Chianti Classico '17 San Vincenti, IT $62.00

For the Table 6 dishes

  • Wild Fennel Mussels $22.00

    Local wild fennel shallots, herb butter, white wine, pernod, and grilled sourdough.

  • Fritto Misto Della Casa $24.00

    Dairy free, gluten free. Local seafood, North fork harvest vegetables, fresh herbs mignonette, and Calabrian chili aioli. GLUTEN + DAIRY FREE

  • Grilled Local Sourdough Bread $14.00

    1610 Sourdough, Regionally Sourced. Organic Flour, Honey Butter, Tomato Jam.

  • Grilled Shishito Peppers $15.00

    Gluten free, vegan. Furikake Seasoning, Imported Olive Oil, Malden Salt, Charred Lemon. VEGAN + GLUTEN FREE

  • Charred Lemon Caesar Salad* $20.00

    House-made dressing, prima Donna cheese, fresh dill, and crispy croissant croutons.

  • 'Not Your Mamas' Mezze $23.00

    Local beet hummus mint raita, ezme, grilled olives, and marinated feta cheese.

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

If you’re wandering through Southold, New York, and craving a spot that balances a laid-back vibe with a touch of sophistication, Little Fish at 50 N Sea Dr is worth checking out. From the moment you approach, the outdoor seating area hints at a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere, perfect for sipping a morning coffee or enjoying a sunset cocktail. Inside, the restaurant continues the approachable yet stylish aesthetic, making it easy to settle in for either a casual lunch or a more indulgent dinner. The menu is a playful mix of small plates, organic dishes, and vegan-friendly options, giving everyone-from plant-based eaters to comfort food lovers-a reason to linger. Drinks are clearly a highlight here, with a well-curated selection of wine, beer, cocktails, and even hard liquor to complement the flavors of the dishes. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite via takeout, enjoying a leisurely dine-in experience, or ordering delivery to relax at home, Little Fish makes it easy to tailor your visit to your mood. The combination of fresh ingredients, creative plating, and thoughtful pairings makes each visit feel a little special, whether it’s a midday pick-me-up coffee or an evening of sharing plates with friends. Plus, the staff brings a friendly, attentive energy that adds to the overall charm, making you feel more like a guest than just a customer. With its mix of quality food, inviting service, and versatile dining options, Little Fish feels like a hidden gem along Southold’s coastal stretch, offering something memorable for both locals and visitors.

Other menus in Southold

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Southold listings
Call Menu Directions